*note this is from an old website I use to write for*
When I was in high school my friend came to me. He needed help with a game he was playing, and knew I liked puzzle type games and figured I could help. He handed me Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney, and the rest was history.
Phoenix Wright has become one of my favorite gaming series since then. Own all of the games, as well as the Miles Edgeworth spin offs and the Manga. I don’t think I have found a series of games that has challenged me, and entertained me as much as the Wright games and I cannot wait for more.
So, here are my top 10 favorite Phoenix Wright cases. I’m going to have a few rules to this list. No final cases. If I did that, the top 5 of the list would be the cases. Also, no spin off games, so sorry Edgeworth Cases and Apollo Justice this is going to be all Phoenix. I will include the newest game in the series though, even if you do not play as Phoenix for all of the cases. Also, I am not going to spoil any of the cases, if you have played them you should remember the ending, I don’t want to spoil it for people who might not have.
10. Turnabout Big Top – When creating this list, at first I didn’t remember this case very well. This Phoenix wright has the least amount of cases, the last one being one of the longest. After I replayed it, I found that it had a lot of color full characters that kept the story interesting. I mean that puppet! I have a soft spot for jerk puppets. This is also the game that started the trend of clowns in Phoenix games. Moe wasn’t funny but he reminded me of a happy uncle who thinks he is funny. Regina bothered me a lot. I just didn’t understand her naive nature was not believable. Her father was the victim in this case, and she just didn’t seem to understand that he died.
As for the case, the twist was very believable; especiallybecause it involved Regina’s lack of emotional connection to people.
9. Turnabout Academy- This case comes from the newest Phoenix Wright game to come to America. It is one of those cases that you are not Phoenix but the newest member of the team Athena. This case was, surprising. It was nice to see Prosecutor Gavin make an appearance. He was one of my favorite characters from the Apollo Justice games besides Trucy Wright. Phoenix games are sometimes played out of order, so it was odd to see a character that we already met act differently.When I mentioned surprising, it wasn’t just because of Gavin making a cameo. There were a few character revelations that I didn’t expect. This case centered around 3 friends who all have something to hide. Athena pulls threw as a rookie, and is really starting to prove herself as a lawyer, this being her debut case.
If I do have a complaint, the actual killer was easy to pick out, and the climax was a little on the stranger end. Still fun though, I got a lot of laughs.
8. The Monstrous Turnabout- Also from the newest Phoenix Wright game and in my opinion it is stronger than Turnabout Academy. This being the second case in the game, Phoenix gives the player a handicap by showing who the real murderer is in an opening cut scene. For the rest of the game this doesn’t happen. If that had been taken out, the case would have been more surprising. This case was very fun besides knowing who the killer was the whole time. I liked the introduction of Japanese superstitions and demons. The wrestling concept did seem out of place though. It ties into the motive of the murder and that I have to admit was a little weak.
7. The Stolen Turnabout- By far this is my favorite Phoenix game. Trials and Tribulations have the best cases, best characters and the most evil villain I have ever encountered. We will get back to her later though.
This case involves a thief and a murder, rather than just the latter. I think this is the only case that involves a thief now that I think about it, other than that, this case that keeps you on your toes. The whole story for this is really in the court rather than the investigation. That is all thanks to prosecutor Godot. He is by far one of the most interesting characters in Phoenix Wright. He is a mystery to Phoenix and the player until the very final case. He says this is his first case, and has a grudge agents Phoenix, but won’t explain why. This grudge makes everything more entertaining because of the way Godot treats Phoenix and uses every little thing to throw back at him.
The villain is fun I guess. I was surprised to find how he pulled off his crimes, and what his motivation was. They had given hints about everything, but it wasn’t until the final (mad) confession that it all came together.
6. Reunion, and Turnabout- This is the case that introduces one of my favorite characters of the series, Perl Fay. At the ending of the first Phoenix Wright game Maya returned to her village to study harder so she can a stronger Sprit Medium. One of the underlining themes in Phoenix Wright is that the Fay family can summon sprits, this normally ends up with Maya (and Perl) summoning the sprite of Phoenix’s mentor Mia Fay when the cases is about to fall apart. I guess I like this case so much because it involves Perl and the first “gimmick” introduced to the games, Psych h Locks. The story is ultimately what draws me to the case. Anything involving the Fay sisters is gold for me. For the second case in the game, it does get pretty complex. More is learned about Sprit Mediums and how the Fay family isn’t as innocent as we first thought.
5. DL-6-I don’t know if this one counts, but I’m adding it in anyway. This was a case that is grouped along with Turnabout Goodbyes, were you solve a 15 year old murder before it is closed forever. This is the case that connects most of the episodes in Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney. This led our favorite Prosecutor to become who he is. It had Mia also decide to go into the Law to help defend her family’s reputation (more on that later). This is why Phoenix became a lawyer as well, so he could help Edgeworth.
Besides being important, this is the first case where you take down a challenging villain. The one man in the series that has done nothing but insult (and assault) you, since you faced him. This was the final case in the original Phoenix Wright when it debuted in Japan for the GBA, and they added another case for the DS that’s why I can get away with this, and the next case.
4. Turnabout Memories- This is the only first case in game I have on this list. Mostly because a lot of the time it is s tutorial for new players, but this one isn’t just that. This case sets the stage for (in my opinion) the best of the Phoenix Wright games because here is where we are introduced to where it all began. Mia Fay defending Phoenix wright. This wasn’t her first trial (We will get to that) this is the trial that she needed to do. Phoenix has been accused of murder (who hasn’t in this game) and Mia defends him because of the witness to the case. Yes, this is the introduction of Dahlia Hawthorn.
The case is an easy one, it is the tutorial case, but I feel like they created it knowing that players who know the Phoenix wright games picked it up so they added a decent challenge and twist.
A lot involves how Dahlia had given Phoenix a necklace the first time she met him, in that very court room six month prior. Every single day she asked him, “please give the necklace back” but Phoenix saw it as a sign of their love, and frequently showed it off. It’s really funny to see Phoenix as a love-sick crybaby, and for the first time you want to strangle him because he is acting so stupid. If he only knew what secrets that necklace held. I want to keep this short, there is always time to talk about Dahlia Hawthorn.
3. Turnabout Sisters-This was the first case where you knew that anything can happen in a Phoenix Wright game. I think that this case became more significant after playing the later games because this is where it really all began. This is when Phoenix first meets Maya Fay, and has to defend her (not the last time he does this sadly). Maya was accused of killing her sister Mia. Looking back, you can see how much of a loss this is to Phoenix and Maya but also the game itself. After playing as Mia in the later games, you wonder what would have been different if she was there the whole time.
Yet, this is a classic story trope. The mentor has to die in order for the pupil to ever achieve greatness.
This is another one of those cases where you know who did it, and because it is Mia you cannot wait to see him get taken down. This event is connection to the DL-6 incident, and where you first hear about it. This is where Phoenix truly became a character to admire, and where the Maya and Phoenix duo began.
2. Turnabout Goodbyes- Oh Edggy Poo!!! Remember way back in the beginning of the article I said that my friend was having trouble, this was the case he handed me. I had no idea what was going on, who any of these characters were, but I became hooked. After playing the game in the proper order this was the first time I began to like Edgeworth as a character. I’m not normally a fan of “emo” guys and this is as emo as you can get, but I wanted to help Edgeworth just as much as Phoenix did. This case is a great example of how the characters in Phoenix wright change from case to case. That everything that happens (even little and out of place moments) effects how the character arcs. Capcom isn’t normally known for their writing, but these games are the exception to that.
I can’t forget Lotta Heart as well, she appears randomly in the series again, and is a lot of fun to have. She is a southern girl always trying to get famous. She may have seemed like a burden at first, but if it wasn’t for her the case would have been lost.
The Case right….Edgeworth is accused of murder this time, and (even though he doesn’t like it) Phoenix basically forces to defend him. Everything relates to the DL-6 innocent from the real murderer to motive, and why Edgeworth originally lost hope.
If I had allowed myself to put final cases on this list, my Number One spot would have gone to Bridge to the Turnabout. This, I think was planned on being the true ending to Phoenix Wright, and I think I would be happy with it if it was. Everything was wrapped up nicely between the three games. This cases involves little plot points from every case.
Turnabout Sister, Reunion, and Turnabout, Turnabout Memories, and my number one spot.
1.
Turnabout Beginnings- My number one case ironically doesn’t have Phoenix in it at all. No, this case is all Mia, and I love it. She by far is one of the greatest characters in the Phoenix Wright games, and I don’t care if that sounds bias.
This is the case that started Mia’s carrier, and also the case that helped her become the lawyer she wanted to. My friend, this is where we learned the true evil that is Dahlia Hawthorn.Mia’s client is a convicted felon who has been accused of a second murder. Five years ago he was sentenced to death for the murder of a 14 year old girl by throwing her off of a bridge. This time he is accused of killing the policewoman who first arrested him, Valerie Hawthorn, on the very same bridge that she arrested him on.
This was not only Mia’s first case but Edgeworth’s as well, and what a first case it turned out to be for both of them.
The only witness to this case is a 19 year old collage girl by the name of Melissa Foster. The player knows that she looks very familiar to criminal that showed up in the first case of this game, Turnabout Memories, but this is the first time Mia would meet her. The witness claimed she was taking pictures for school when she witnessed Terry stab Valerie and shove her into the trunk of a car.
The true identity of Melissa is eventually revealed as Dahlia, and it leads to the mysterious accounts of Five years ago when she was said to be dead because Terry threw her off of the very bridge that he met Valerie.
Dahlia is the center of everything. She is the reason why Terry was put in jail, and why he escaped to meet with Valerie. Dahlia, five years ago convinced Terry (who was much older than she was) that they were in love, and should run away together, stealing a gem from her father so they would have money. Valerie knew about this and wanted to help them, she knew that Dahlia actually threw herself off that bridge that day and survived. No one knew about a pact that Dahlia and Terry had made, that when the going went tough they would choose death together. Only Dahlia didn’t choose death, and Terry believed to the very end that she wouldn’t betray him.
This case is the reason why I hate Dahlia and love her as a character. She was 14 years old when she tricked Terry. Five years later she tricked Phoenix all the same. She is where it all began for Mia, Edgeworth, Phoenix, and Godot. I wish I could spoil, but my lips are sealed.
So that is my top ten Phoenix Wright cases. I cannot wait till 2014 for when Phoenix Wright X Professor Layton comes to America , here is too many more Phoenix Wright games to come!!!
Also, always remember “The only time a lawyer can cry, is when it’s all over.”